The 25 Best Insurance Agencies in Bellingham
Home, auto, life, and business insurance. Ranked from 2,924 Google reviews across the Bellingham area.
- Updated November 2026
- 39 met the bar
- 4.77 average rating
The short answerThe highest ranked insurance agencies in Bellingham right now are The Baldwin Group Health Insurance (5.0 stars, 236 reviews), Trucordia - Rimland Dr. (4.9 stars, 732 reviews), and Tim Slesk - State Farm Insurance Agent (4.9 stars, 423 reviews). They come out on top of 39 eligible businesses after weighting each rating by its review volume.
- 1
The Baldwin Group Health Insurance
Insurance company - 2
Trucordia - Rimland Dr.
Insurance agency - 3
Tim Slesk - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance agency
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- 25
How this list was made
We pulled 100 Bellingham-area insurance agencies from Google Maps, then kept the 39 with a rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 10 reviews. The average rating in this group is 4.77 stars.
Ratings with only a few reviews are pulled toward that average, so a business needs a real track record to reach the top. Nobody pays to be here. Read the full method.
- Businesses reviewed
- 100
- Met the bar
- 39
- Average rating
- 4.77
- Reviews behind this list
- 2,924
Questions people ask
Who is the best insurance agency in Bellingham?
As of November 2026, The Baldwin Group Health Insurance ranks first among 39 eligible Bellingham insurance agencies, with a 5.0 star Google rating across 236 reviews. Trucordia - Rimland Dr. and Tim Slesk - State Farm Insurance Agent round out the top three.
Which Bellingham insurance agencies have the most reviews?
Of the 25 insurance agencies ranked on this page, Trucordia - Rimland Dr. (732), Tim Slesk - State Farm Insurance Agent (423), and Sierra Belleville - State Farm Insurance Agent (314) have the most Google reviews.
How did you rank these insurance agencies?
We started with 100 Bellingham-area businesses from Google Maps and kept the 39 with at least a 4.0 star rating and 10 or more reviews. Each rating is then weighted by how many reviews back it up, so a perfect score from a handful of reviews does not outrank a near-perfect score from hundreds.
Can a business pay to rank higher?
No. Positions come only from public Google ratings and review volume. Claiming or updating a listing is free and does not change its rank.
More professional services in Bellingham
Own a Bellingham business?
Every listing is free. Claim yours to correct your phone, hours, or website, or tell us about a category we are missing. Claiming never changes a rank.
